A novel class of CGRP receptor antagonists was rationally designed by modifying a highly potent, but structurally complex, CGRP receptor antagonist. Initial modifications focused on simplified structures, with increased flexibility. Subsequent to the preparation of a less-potent but more flexible lead, classic medicinal chemistry methods were applied to restore high affinity (compound 22, CGRP Ki=0.035 nM) while maintaining structural diversity relative to the lead. Good selectivity against the closely related adrenomedullin-2 receptor was also achieved.